St John the Evangelist, Burgess Hill Mystery or misery? Trinity 16 (25A) 20 September 2026

God is like us, yet gloriously different. In Christ, God shares our humanity and opens it to resurrection glory. Christianity holds joy and sorrow, darkness and light together: mystery instead of misery. Alleluia!

We are God’s children having a ‘sameness’ to God, no less.

God-like we may be but we are also ‘different’ from God – or rather God is different from us.

We are made like God through baptism, adopted sons and daughters – and yet we are called to purify ourselves as he is pure (1 John 3:3). We are like God but we are also not like God.

Christianity thrills with mystery and paradox.  Look at that Gospel reading and how far God’s sense can be from common sense – paying all your workers the same however long or short their hours? (Matthew 20:15)

When God comes among us into the world he wants to be the same as us – so he plumbs our human depths. He suffers. Yet in coming to us as God, so very different to us, he is able to open up our humanity to generous, endless vistas in the revelation of resurrection glory!

Christianity is about the bursting out of resurrection glory from the Risen Christ as shafts of light so often diffract from the sun through dark clouds.

Have you seen that picture, often at sunset – those who live in the Caribbean know it better than us – the sun’s glory bursting out through the clouds.

What a picture – darkness and light together showing each other off!

So God shows himself off to us in Christ crucified and risen! God shows himself off in full splendour and lifts our poor humanity in the process, making it a vehicle and instrument of divine glory.

I love paradox.  The dictionary states that a paradox occurs when two statements that are contradictory in logic must be held together in experience. As a youth I acted in the Pirates of Penzance where Frederick, apprenticed to the Pirates, prepares for freedom on his 21st birthday. Then Ruth, his fierce protectress breaks the news that he is not 21 but only 5 and ‘a little bit over’ since he was born on 29 February. They sing the great ‘Paradox’ duet, which marks the necessity for Frederick to remain a pirate until he is 84.  The chorus runs: ‘How quaint the ways of paradox, at common sense she gaily mocks…’

Paradoxes are amusing mentally.  They ‘mock common sense’ by provoking us to look at things two ways at once and get different answers. 

Christianity is famous for its paradoxes – God in Three yet One, Jesus is God yet Man, Christ has died, Christ is risen…   Look at Paul in the second reading, ‘to me, living is Christ and dying is gain’. If I am to live in the flesh, that means fruitful labour for me; and I do not know which I prefer. I am hard pressed between the two: my desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better’. The apostle makes life and death into a paradox only Christian faith could entertain – living is Christ and dying is gain.

Some of us have been through some very dark periods in our lives. Again and again sharing with Christian believers I catch vivid evidence of how the presence of faith allows dark clouds in life to diffract the glory of the Lord.  We need to hear more about this in our own Christian community so as to build us up in heart and soul.

Joy and Sorrow are our inseparable bedfellows in this mysterious Christianity of ours. When you struggle with your faith imagine a world without this mystery you struggle with. It’s not very hard to imagine it because such a world is all around us! Think of the misery and complaining of the Israelites in our Old Testament misery and the subsequent mystery of bread from heaven, itself a pointer to the mystery of the Mass which enfolds our own miseries with the embrace of divine love.  

Misery or mystery is the choice, really. 

Take away one side of the paradox and where does it leave you – the mystery of life is reduced to a bare contradiction.

Make God the same as us.  Eat, drink and be merry – this is where God is, right with us, the same as us.  Where is hope in such materialism?  As if there were nothing beyond death?  Other world views like Buddhism also make God the same as us – God is the self, he is the genie in our lamp, so to speak.  God is so much the same as us he is built in our image more than we are built in his!

The paradox is lost – one side of the mystery of being is denied.

Or to look at the other extreme there are people who go about excessively making God different to everyone else.  Zip him up in the Quran, God so different and aloof.  Sometimes the Church too zips God up and makes him so special people feel they can never reach him.

You lose the sameness of God in all of this.

Christ who is the same as us has the capacity to empathise and to draw out our sin and fear and doubt.

Christ who is ever new and so different to us also has the capacity to refresh us with his Spirit.  As the stone got rolled back on Easter Day so the same Lord is present in our lives to make a difference and roll back the stones that weigh us down – stones of grief and sorrow, of bitterness and unforgiveness, of confusion and doubt. 

Our Lord brings mystery instead of misery – he fills out the picture of life for us – and can fill out the picture of life for others as we share the good news. God has come to be the same as us and to make a difference to us and to the whole world!  Alleluia Christ is risen!  He is risen indeed alleluia!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top